Coercive and Controlling Behaviour

An allegation of coercive and controlling behaviour is an extremely serious matter. Introduced as a specific offence in recent years, it is designed to address patterns of psychological and emotional abuse within intimate or family relationships. An investigation or charge can have a profound and devastating impact on your life, reputation, and family relationships, even before a case reaches court. If you are facing an accusation of coercive and controlling behaviour, it is absolutely essential to seek immediate, expert legal advice to protect your rights and your future.

At Central Chambers Law, our senior legal consultants are experts in defending individuals against the most sensitive and complex allegations, including coercive control. We understand the nuances of this area of law, the nature of the evidence involved, and how to build a robust defence against claims that often span a long period. Our function is to provide authoritative, discreet, and strategic representation to challenge the prosecution’s narrative and secure the best possible outcome for you.

What is Coercive and Controlling Behaviour? The Legal Definition

The offence of coercive and controlling behaviour is created by Section 76 of the Serious Crime Act 2015. It is not about a single incident but a pattern of behaviour over time.

A person commits this offence if they repeatedly or continuously engage in behaviour towards another person that is controlling or coercive, and at the time of the behaviour, the two people are personally connected. The behaviour must also have a "serious effect" on the other person, and the accused must know or ought to know that it will have a serious effect.

Breaking Down the Offence

For a conviction, the prosecution must prove several distinct elements:

1. Repeated or Continuous Behaviour

The law targets a pattern of conduct, not isolated arguments or actions. The prosecution must demonstrate that the behaviour happened on more than one occasion.

2. Personally Connected

The offence can only be committed between individuals who are "personally connected." This means they must be in an intimate relationship, former partners who still live together, or family members.

3. Controlling or Coercive

This is the core of the offence. The law does not provide a strict definition, but guidance includes a wide range of conduct:

• Isolating a person from their friends and family.
• Monitoring their time or communications (e.g., checking their phone).
• Controlling their finances.
• Repeatedly putting them down.
• Threatening to harm them, a child, or a pet.
• Enforcing rules designed to humiliate or degrade.

4. Serious Effect

The behaviour must have had a "serious effect" on the victim. This has two possible meanings:

• It has caused the victim to fear, on at least two occasions, that violence will be used against them.
• It has caused the victim serious alarm or distress which has a substantial adverse effect on their usual day-to-day activities.

The Penalties for Coercive and Controlling Behaviour

This is an "either-way" offence, meaning it can be heard in either the Magistrates' Court or the Crown Court. A conviction carries significant penalties:

• Prison Sentence: The maximum sentence upon conviction in the Crown Court is five years' imprisonment.
• Criminal Record: A conviction will result in a criminal record for a serious offence, which can have a major impact on your career, professional registrations, and ability to travel.
• Restraining Orders: The court will likely impose a restraining order, which can prevent you from contacting the complainant and even from attending the family home.

Building a Defence to an Allegation of Coercive Control

These cases are often highly complex, based on one person's account of a relationship over many months or years. An expert solicitor can deconstruct the allegations and build a powerful defence.

Potential defences include:

• Factual Dispute: Challenging the complainant’s version of events and arguing that the behaviour described did not happen or has been exaggerated or taken out of context.
• No Serious Effect: Arguing that while the relationship may have been unhappy, the behaviour did not cause a "serious effect" as defined by the law.
• Not Controlling or Coercive: Demonstrating that the behaviour, when viewed in the full context of the relationship, was not controlling or coercive in nature.
• Belief that the Behaviour was in the Best Interests: The law provides a defence if the accused can show they believed the behaviour was in the best interests of the victim and that belief was reasonable.

Why Central Chambers Law Provides the Definitive Defence

Defending an allegation of coercive control requires a legal team with the sensitivity to handle delicate personal matters and the forensic skill to analyse evidence that spans a long period.

Clients trust Central Chambers Law because we provide a strategic, non-judgmental, and meticulously prepared defence. Our reputation is built on our ability to identify the weaknesses in a prosecution case built on narrative and interpretation. Our approach involves:

• Immediate and Discreet Advice: We understand the personal and sensitive nature of these allegations. We provide urgent, confidential advice to protect your position from the very first contact with police.
• Forensic Analysis of the Narrative: We meticulously scrutinise the entire history presented by the prosecution, analysing digital communications, witness accounts, and other evidence to find inconsistencies and build a counter-narrative.
• Proactive Case Building: We actively seek evidence that supports your account of the relationship, identifying defence witnesses and context that challenges the prosecution’s claims.
• Skilled and Sensitive Advocacy: Our senior advocates are experts at cross-examining complainants in a sensitive yet effective manner and presenting your case to a jury with clarity and authority.

Our focused expertise means we are perfectly equipped to provide the intelligent and robust representation needed to protect your liberty and reputation.

Protect Your Future with Immediate Legal Advice

If you have been arrested, charged, or asked to attend an interview regarding coercive and controlling behaviour, you are in a perilous legal situation. The allegations can shatter your life before a trial even begins. Do not face this process alone.

Contact our expert criminal defence solicitors immediately for an urgent and confidential consultation. Taking immediate action is the most important step towards building a strong defence.

‍