Corporate Manslaughter

A corporate manslaughter investigation is one of the most serious and complex legal challenges a company and its senior management can face. This offence alleges that a profound failure in how a company was managed led directly to a person's death. Investigations are conducted by the police and the Health and Safety Executive (HSE), are incredibly intrusive, and can last for years. A conviction can result in an unlimited fine, a devastating publicity order, and irreparable reputational damage, potentially destroying a successful business.

At Central Chambers Law, our senior legal consultants are experts in defending companies and directors facing these grave allegations. We understand the intricate legal framework and the immense pressure of a corporate manslaughter investigation. Our function is to provide an immediate, strategic defence that manages the investigation, protects the company and its individuals, and meticulously challenges the prosecution's case. We are specialists with the deep knowledge required to navigate these high-stakes, document-heavy cases from start to finish.

Understanding the Offence: What is Corporate Manslaughter?

Corporate manslaughter is a criminal offence created by the Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007. The Act was introduced to make it easier to prosecute companies and large organisations for the most serious health and safety failings that result in death.

An organisation is guilty of the offence if the way in which its activities are managed or organised causes a person's death and amounts to a "gross breach" of a relevant duty of care owed by the organisation to the deceased. The crucial point is that the failure must be on the part of the organisation's "senior management." Individuals cannot be prosecuted for the offence itself, but the investigation will intensely scrutinise their actions, and they can face separate charges for gross negligence manslaughter or health and safety breaches.

The Key Elements of the Offence

For a company to be convicted of corporate manslaughter, the prosecution must prove several key elements beyond a reasonable doubt:

1. The Organisation is a Qualifying One: This includes most corporations, government departments, and police forces.
2. A Relevant Duty of Care was Owed: The organisation must have owed a duty of care to the victim under the law of negligence (e.g., an employer's duty to an employee, or a company's duty to a member of the public).
3. Gross Breach of that Duty: The way the company's activities were managed or organised must have fallen far below what could reasonably be expected, constituting a "gross" breach.
4. A "Substantial Element" of the Breach was by Senior Management: The prosecution must prove that the way activities were managed by senior leadership was a substantial part of the breach. "Senior management" refers to individuals who play significant roles in making policy or managing the whole or a substantial part of the organisation's activities.
5. Causation: The gross breach of duty must have been a significant cause of the victim's death.

The entire case depends on proving a systemic, senior-level management failure that resulted in a fatality.

How Corporate Manslaughter Cases are Investigated

Investigations are joint operations between the police and the Health and Safety Executive (HSE). They are forensic, intrusive, and can take years to conclude.

Common investigative methods include:

• Scene Preservation: Securing the site of the incident for detailed forensic examination.
• Seizure of Documents: Taking vast quantities of company records, including risk assessments, board meeting minutes, internal audits, and policy documents.
• Digital Forensics: Seizing computers and servers to analyse emails and internal communications between managers and employees.
• Interviews: Conducting formal interviews under caution with a wide range of individuals, from senior directors to junior staff, to understand how the company was managed in practice.
• Expert Reports: Commissioning experts to report on industry standards and the specific failings that led to the death.

The investigators' goal is to build a detailed picture of a company's culture and systems to prove a gross breach of duty at a senior level.

Why Central Chambers Law Provides the Definitive Defence

Defending a corporate manslaughter allegation requires a legal team with specialist expertise in both criminal law and health and safety regulations. The ability to manage a major crisis and interact with multiple investigating bodies is crucial.

Clients trust Central Chambers Law because we are experts in handling these complex and sensitive cases. Our reputation is built on our strategic crisis management and our ability to forensically deconstruct the prosecution’s case. Our approach involves:

• Immediate Crisis Management: We take control from day one, managing communications with the police and HSE, advising the board, and preserving evidence to protect the company's position.
• Challenging the 'Gross Breach': We build a powerful case to show that the company's conduct did not fall "far below" the expected standard. We instruct leading industry experts to provide evidence that the company's systems and procedures were reasonable and compliant.
• Disputing Senior Management Failure: We challenge the prosecution's assertion that the failing was at a senior level. We work to demonstrate that any issues were the result of individual actions contrary to company policy, rather than a systemic management failure.
• Contesting Causation: We meticulously examine the chain of events to challenge the link between the alleged breach and the death. We explore alternative causes and intervening acts that could break the chain of causation.

Our focused expertise means we are perfectly equipped to provide the robust, high-level strategic defence required when the very future of a business is at stake.

Consequences of a Conviction

A conviction for corporate manslaughter can be catastrophic for a business.

• Unlimited Fine: The starting point for a fine is typically in the millions of pounds, calculated as a percentage of the company's turnover.
• Publicity Order: The court can force the company to publicise the fact of its conviction, the details of the offence, and the amount of the fine. This causes immense reputational damage.
• Remedial Order: The court can order the company to take steps to remedy the failings that led to the death.

While the company is the entity prosecuted, the fallout for the directors and senior managers involved can be career-ending.

Protect Your Business with an Expert Defence

A corporate manslaughter investigation is a corporate crisis of the highest order. The decisions you make in the first hours and days after a fatal incident will have a profound impact on the outcome.

Do not face this complex legal challenge without expert guidance. Contact our specialist corporate crime solicitors immediately for a confidential consultation and take the first critical step in protecting your business and its people.

‍