Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC)

When the normal appeals process has been exhausted and a wrongful conviction still stands, it can feel like all hope is lost. The Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) exists as the last resort for those who have suffered a miscarriage of justice. The CCRC is an independent public body set up to investigate potential miscarriages of justice in England, Wales, and Northern Ireland. Applying to the CCRC is a complex and demanding process that requires an expertly prepared case. Success depends on presenting new arguments or evidence in a way that persuades the Commission to refer your case back to the Court of Appeal.

At Central Chambers Law, our senior legal consultants are specialists in challenging wrongful convictions, including making formidable applications to the CCRC. We understand that a successful application requires a forensic examination of the original case and a compelling presentation of new information. Our function is to leave no stone unturned in our pursuit of justice for our clients. We are specialists with the deep knowledge required to navigate this final, critical stage of the legal process.

Understanding the CCRC: The Last Hope for Justice

The CCRC was established by the Criminal Appeal Act 1995. It is the only body that can refer a case back to the appeal courts for a fresh appeal after the normal appeal process has been completed. Its role is not to decide guilt or innocence but to determine if there is a "real possibility" that the Court of Appeal will overturn the conviction or reduce the sentence.

The CCRC is entirely independent of the courts, police, and government. It has extensive legal powers to obtain documents from public and private bodies, such as police files, court records, and social services documents, allowing it to conduct a thorough and wide-ranging investigation into a case.

The CCRC Application Process

Applying to the CCRC is a significant undertaking. The Commission receives hundreds of applications each year and will only refer a small fraction of them back to the courts.

The process typically involves:

1. Initial Application: You submit a detailed application form along with all relevant documents. This must clearly set out the reasons why you believe your conviction or sentence is wrong.
2. Case Review: A CCRC Case Review Manager will be assigned to your case. They will conduct an impartial and thorough review of all the evidence from your trial and any new information you have provided.
3. The 'Real Possibility' Test: The core of the CCRC's decision-making is whether they believe there is a "real possibility" that the Court of Appeal would not uphold the conviction if the case were referred back to them. This usually requires significant new evidence or a powerful new legal argument that was not raised at the original trial or appeal.

This test is a high bar to meet, and a successful application must be built on solid foundations.

Why Central Chambers Law Provides the Definitive Representation

Submitting a successful CCRC application requires a level of legal skill and forensic analysis that goes beyond standard criminal defence. It involves identifying what went wrong at the original trial and building an entirely new case to prove that a miscarriage of justice has occurred.

Clients trust Central Chambers Law for this highly specialised work because we are experts in appellate law. Our reputation is built on our meticulous investigative approach and our ability to construct powerful, persuasive applications. Our strategic approach involves:

• Forensic Case Deconstruction: We conduct an exhaustive review of every piece of paper from the original case. We are searching for overlooked evidence, undisclosed material, or legal errors that form the basis of a compelling CCRC application.
• Uncovering New Evidence: We do not simply rely on the existing case files. We actively seek out new evidence, which can involve tracing new witnesses, instructing new forensic experts, or identifying flaws in the original scientific evidence.
• Drafting an Irrefutable Application: Our core skill is presenting your case to the CCRC in the most powerful way possible. We draft clear, detailed, and compelling applications that directly address the "real possibility" test and leave the Commission in no doubt as to the merits of your case.
• Expert Guidance Throughout: We manage the entire process, liaising with the CCRC on your behalf and responding to any queries from the Case Review Manager, ensuring your case is presented professionally at every stage.

Our focused expertise means we know exactly what the CCRC needs to see to refer a case, giving you the best possible chance of getting your case back before the Court of Appeal.

Potential Outcomes of a CCRC Application

After its investigation, the CCRC will make its decision.

• Referral: If the Commission decides there is a real possibility the conviction is unsafe, it will refer the case to the Court of Appeal. This is a major victory, as the Court of Appeal will then hear a fresh appeal.
• Refusal: If the CCRC does not believe the test has been met, it will decline to refer the case. It will provide detailed reasons for its decision.

There is no time limit for applying to the CCRC, but the process of gathering evidence and preparing a strong case can be lengthy.

Fight a Miscarriage of Justice with Expert Representation

Being the victim of a wrongful conviction is a profound injustice. The CCRC offers a final, vital route to clearing your name, but it is a difficult path that demands the highest level of legal expertise.

Do not give up the fight for justice. Contact our expert appeal solicitors immediately for a confidential consultation and take the first critical step in building a powerful application to the CCRC.

‍