Exceptional Hardship Arguments

Accumulating 12 or more penalty points on your driving licence typically results in an automatic "totting-up" disqualification for a minimum of six months. For many, this is a catastrophic event, threatening their job, family life, and financial stability. However, the law provides a critical opportunity to avoid this ban: the exceptional hardship argument. This is a specific legal plea made to the court, arguing that a disqualification would cause hardship that is not merely inconvenient but truly exceptional. Successfully making this argument is the only way to keep your licence in this situation, and it requires expert preparation and advocacy.

At Central Chambers Law, our senior legal consultants are experts in road traffic law and have a formidable track record in successfully presenting exceptional hardship arguments. We understand that losing your licence can have devastating consequences. Our function is to build a detailed, persuasive case on your behalf, gathering the necessary evidence and presenting it with force and clarity in court. We are specialists in this area, dedicated to protecting your licence and your livelihood.

Understanding the Process: What is an Exceptional Hardship Argument?

An exceptional hardship argument is a plea for mitigation made under Section 35 of the Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988. It is not a defence to the motoring offence itself, but rather a submission made at the sentencing stage after you have pleaded guilty or been found guilty. It asks the court to exercise its discretion not to impose the mandatory totting-up disqualification because of the severe impact it would have.

The key word is "exceptional." The court will assume that any disqualification will cause hardship, such as difficulty getting to work or taking children to school. To succeed, you must prove that the hardship you (or, more importantly, others who depend on you) would suffer goes far beyond what would ordinarily be expected.

What Constitutes "Exceptional Hardship"?

The legal test is high, and the court will scrutinise your case carefully. There is no exhaustive list of what counts as exceptional hardship, as each case is decided on its own facts. However, successful arguments are typically built around the severe and unavoidable impact on innocent third parties.

Common grounds for exceptional hardship include:

• Loss of Employment: This is the most common ground, but simply losing your job is often not enough. You must demonstrate that the loss of employment would lead to exceptional consequences, such as the inability to pay your mortgage leading to repossession, or the failure of a business you own, causing your employees to lose their jobs.
• Impact on Dependent Relatives: If you are the sole carer for a disabled, elderly, or seriously ill family member and you rely on your licence to transport them to essential medical appointments, this can form a strong basis for an argument.
• Severe Financial Hardship: You would need to show that a disqualification would lead to more than just a reduction in income. It would need to lead to a genuine inability to meet essential financial commitments, impacting your family's welfare.
• Impact on Your Community: In rare cases, individuals in roles vital to a small community (such as a specialised tradesperson or a community carer) may be able to argue that their disqualification would cause exceptional hardship to those who rely on their services.

The court is primarily concerned with the effect of a ban on innocent people. An argument focused solely on your own inconvenience is highly unlikely to succeed.

The Court Process for Presenting Your Case

If you face a totting-up ban, you will be required to attend a hearing at the Magistrates' Court. This is where your exceptional hardship argument must be made.

The process involves:

1. Case Preparation: This is the most critical stage. It involves gathering comprehensive written evidence to support every point you intend to make. This can include letters from employers, medical professionals, accountants, and family members, as well as financial documents.
2. Sworn Testimony: You will be required to go into the witness box and give live evidence under oath. You will explain your circumstances to the court and be cross-examined by the prosecutor, who will test the strength of your evidence.
3. Legal Submissions: Your legal representative will make a closing submission to the magistrates, summarising the evidence and persuading them that the hardship threshold has been met.
4. The Decision: The magistrates will then decide whether your argument has been successful. They can choose to disqualify you for the full period, disqualify you for a shorter period, or not disqualify you at all.

Why Central Chambers Law Provides the Definitive Argument

Presenting a successful exceptional hardship argument is a specialised skill. It requires meticulous preparation and persuasive advocacy. Attempting to represent yourself is a significant risk, as you may not know what evidence is required or how to present it effectively under the pressure of cross-examination.

Clients trust Central Chambers Law because we are experts in this field. Our reputation is built on our detailed and strategic approach to building these cases from the ground up. Our method involves:

• Detailed Case Analysis: We begin with a thorough consultation to identify all potential grounds for exceptional hardship, focusing on the impact on others. We are skilled at uncovering the hidden consequences of a ban that you may not have considered.
• Evidence Gathering Strategy: We provide clear guidance on precisely what evidence is needed to build a compelling case. We help you obtain powerful supporting letters and documents that will withstand the court's scrutiny.
• Meticulous Preparation: We prepare you for giving evidence in court, ensuring you are ready to answer questions clearly and confidently. We leave nothing to chance.
• Expert Advocacy: Our highly experienced court advocates are masters of presenting these arguments. They know how to structure the case, what points to emphasise, and how to persuade the magistrates to exercise their discretion in your favour.

Our focused expertise means we are perfectly equipped to give you the best possible chance of keeping your licence.

Protect Your Licence with an Expert Argument

Facing a totting-up disqualification can be a terrifying prospect. However, with the right legal strategy, it does not have to mean an automatic ban. An expertly prepared and presented exceptional hardship argument can be the difference between keeping your licence and losing your livelihood.

Do not risk your driving licence by facing this complex legal hearing alone. Contact our expert motoring offence solicitors immediately for a confidential consultation and take the first critical step in building your case.

‍