Public Order Act Section 4 (Threatening Behaviour)

An allegation of threatening behaviour under Section 4 of the Public Order Act is a serious matter. These charges often arise from heated arguments or disputes that have escalated, and a conviction can lead to a prison sentence and a criminal record. The impact on your reputation, career, and personal life can be significant. If you have been arrested or are under investigation for a Section 4 offence, it is essential that you seek expert legal advice immediately to protect your rights and build a strong defence.

At Central Chambers Law, our senior legal consultants are experts in defending individuals against all types of public order allegations. We understand the fine legal distinctions, the importance of the evidence, and how to challenge a prosecution case effectively. Our function is to provide clear, authoritative guidance and to ensure your side of the story is presented with skill and precision in court.

What is a Section 4 Public Order Offence?

The offence is created by Section 4 of the Public Order Act 1986. It is designed to deal with situations where a person's threatening, abusive, or insulting behaviour causes another person to fear that immediate violence will be used against them, or where the behaviour is likely to provoke such violence.

For the prosecution to secure a conviction, they must prove several key elements beyond a reasonable doubt:

1. You used threatening, abusive, or insulting words or behaviour.
2. You intended to cause another person to believe that immediate unlawful violence would be used against them (or another person), OR you were aware that your conduct might be threatening, abusive, or insulting and might cause someone to have such a belief.
3. The offence occurred in a public or private place (but it cannot be committed by a person inside a dwelling if the other person is also inside that dwelling).

Breaking Down the Offence

Understanding the specific components of the charge is crucial, as this is where a defence is often built.

"Threatening, Abusive or Insulting"

This is a matter of fact for the court to decide. The words or behaviour must be more than just rude or offensive; they must be of a nature that could genuinely cause fear or provoke violence. The context of the entire incident is highly important.

The Mental Element (Intent)

This is a key part of the offence. The prosecution must prove that you either intended for someone to fear immediate violence, or that you were at least reckless as to whether they would. This subjective element is often a central point of contention in a trial. It is not enough for the prosecution to say you should have known; they must prove you did know your behaviour could have this effect.

"Immediate Unlawful Violence"

The fear must be of violence that is "immediate." A threat of future violence would not be sufficient for a Section 4 charge. The person who is made to feel fear does not have to be the person the threats are aimed at; a witness to the behaviour can be the victim in the eyes of the law.

The Penalties for a Section 4 Conviction

Section 4 is an "either-way" offence, which means it can be heard in either the Magistrates' Court or the Crown Court. The penalties are significant:

• Prison Sentence: The maximum sentence upon conviction in the Crown Court is six months' imprisonment.
• Criminal Record: A conviction for a public order offence involving threats of violence is serious and will result in a criminal record. This can have a major impact on your ability to find employment and travel internationally.
• Fines and Community Orders: The court can also impose substantial fines, community-based punishments like unpaid work, or anger management courses.

Building a Defence to a Section 4 Allegation

Just because you have been charged does not mean you will be convicted. The burden of proof is on the prosecution, and an expert solicitor can identify and advance strong defences.

Potential defences include:

• Lack of Intent: Arguing that you did not intend to cause anyone to fear violence and were not reckless as to whether this would happen. You may have been angry, but this does not automatically mean you had the required criminal intent.
• Self-Defence: Demonstrating that your actions were a necessary, reasonable, and proportionate response to a threat of violence made against you or another person.
• Factual Dispute: Challenging the prosecution’s entire version of events. This could involve arguing that the words were not said, your behaviour was not threatening, or that the complainant has exaggerated or fabricated their account.
• No Fear of "Immediate" Violence: Arguing that any fear caused was not of "immediate" violence, but of something that might happen in the future.

Why Central Chambers Law Provides the Definitive Defence

Defending a Section 4 public order charge requires a legal team that can meticulously analyse the evidence and persuasively argue points of intent and context.

Clients trust Central Chambers Law because we provide a strategic, non-judgmental, and robust defence. Our reputation is built on our ability to deconstruct the prosecution's narrative and find the weaknesses that can lead to a successful outcome. Our approach involves:

• Immediate, Expert Advice: From your first contact with us, we provide clear, confidential advice to protect your legal position, especially before a police interview under caution where what you say is critically important.
• Forensic Evidence Analysis: We rigorously examine all prosecution material, from witness statements and CCTV footage to body-worn video, to identify inconsistencies and build a counter-narrative.
• Proactive Defence Strategy: We actively seek out defence evidence. This may involve tracing independent witnesses or gathering material that provides essential context to the incident and challenges the complainant’s credibility.
• Skilled Courtroom Advocacy: Our senior advocates are experts at cross-examining witnesses and presenting a defence to a judge, jury, or magistrates. We know how to effectively challenge a witness's account and argue your case with authority and skill.

Our focused expertise means we are perfectly equipped to provide the intelligent and robust representation needed to protect your liberty and your good name.

Protect Your Future with Immediate Legal Advice

If you have been arrested, charged, or are under investigation for a Section 4 public order offence, do not underestimate the seriousness of your situation. Every decision you make is critical. You must not face this process alone.

Contact our expert criminal defence solicitors immediately for an urgent and confidential consultation. Taking immediate action is the most important step towards building a strong defence.

‍