Special Reasons Arguments

Certain motoring offences, such as drink driving or driving without insurance, carry mandatory penalties. This means that upon conviction, the court must impose a minimum number of penalty points or a driving disqualification. However, the law allows for a specific legal argument, known as a "special reasons" argument, which can persuade a court not to impose these obligatory penalties. This is not a defence to the charge itself, but a plea that there are unique circumstances directly related to the offence that make it just to waive the usual punishment. Successfully arguing special reasons requires expert legal knowledge and skilled advocacy.

At Central Chambers Law, our senior legal consultants are experts in all facets of road traffic law, including the technicalities of special reasons arguments. We understand the high legal standard that must be met and how to build a case that satisfies the court. Our function is to meticulously prepare your argument, gather the essential supporting evidence, and present your case persuasively to protect your driving licence. We are specialists in this niche area of law, committed to achieving the best possible outcome for you.

Understanding the Concept: What are Special Reasons?

A special reasons argument is a legal submission made to the court after a person has pleaded guilty or been found guilty of a motoring offence that carries a mandatory penalty. It is a plea to the court to exercise its discretion and not endorse the licence with penalty points or impose a disqualification due to the specific facts of the case.

The legal basis is found within the Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988, which gives the court the power to deviate from mandatory sentencing guidelines if it finds that "special reasons" exist. The burden of proof is on the defendant to prove, on the balance of probabilities, that such reasons apply.

For an argument to be successful, it must meet four key criteria established by case law:

1. It must be a mitigating or extenuating circumstance.
2. It must not amount to a legal defence to the charge.
3. It must be directly connected to the commission of the offence.
4. It must be a matter that the court should properly take into consideration when imposing a sentence.

What Constitutes a "Special Reason"?

The courts have set a high bar for what qualifies as a special reason. Mere inconvenience or a mistaken belief is not enough. The circumstances must be truly compelling and directly relevant to why the offence was committed.

Common examples of successful special reasons arguments include:

• Driving in a genuine emergency: This involves driving a very short distance out of necessity to avert a clear and present danger. For example, moving a vehicle to escape the threat of physical harm or driving someone to a hospital in a life-or-death situation where calling an ambulance was not a viable option. The distance driven must be minimal, and the risk must have been genuine.
• A driver’s drink being "laced": If you can prove that you unknowingly consumed alcohol because your drink was spiked, and that you would not have been over the legal limit otherwise, this can amount to a special reason. You must show you had no reason to suspect you were over the limit.
• Driving due to a sudden medical emergency: If an unforeseeable medical emergency compelled you to drive, this may be considered a special reason. This is distinct from a medical issue that provides a full defence (automatism).
• Insurance policy invalidity: For a no insurance offence, a special reason may exist if you were genuinely misled by your insurance company into believing you were covered and had no reasonable grounds to think otherwise.

The court will carefully examine the facts of each case, and success is never guaranteed.

The Court Process for Presenting Your Case

Presenting a special reasons argument is a formal legal process that takes place at a sentencing hearing in the Magistrates' Court.

The process involves:

1. Case Preparation: This is the most critical stage. It involves gathering robust evidence to support your claim. This could include witness statements, medical reports, phone records, or correspondence from an insurance company.
2. Sworn Testimony: You and any supporting witnesses will need to give evidence under oath. You will be cross-examined by the prosecutor, who will challenge your account and test the credibility of your argument.
3. Legal Submissions: Your legal representative will make a formal submission to the magistrates, outlining the legal principles and applying them to the evidence you have presented. They will argue why your circumstances meet the high threshold for special reasons.
4. The Decision: The magistrates will decide if you have successfully proven your case. If they agree that special reasons exist, they have the discretion to impose no penalty points or to avoid a disqualification. If they reject the argument, the standard mandatory penalty will be imposed.

Why Central Chambers Law Provides the Definitive Argument

Successfully arguing special reasons is a complex legal art that requires specialist knowledge and skilled court advocacy. It is not a matter of simply explaining your story to the court. Without expert representation, you risk failing to present the necessary evidence or being unable to handle the pressure of cross-examination.

Clients trust Central Chambers Law because we are experts in road traffic law. Our reputation is built on our meticulous preparation and our persuasive presentation of these technical arguments. Our strategic approach involves:

• Honest and Expert Assessment: We provide a clear and realistic assessment of your chances of success from the outset. We will identify the strengths and weaknesses of your case and advise on the best strategy.
• Evidence-Led Strategy: We guide you on exactly what evidence is required to build a compelling and believable case that will stand up to scrutiny from the prosecutor and the court.
• Meticulous Preparation: We ensure you are fully prepared for your court hearing. We will go through your evidence in detail, so you know what to expect and can present your account with confidence.
• Skilled Court Advocacy: Our experienced advocates are masters of presenting these arguments. They know how to question witnesses effectively and how to construct a legal submission that persuades the court to find in your favour.

Our focused expertise means we are perfectly equipped to give you the strongest possible chance of avoiding mandatory penalties.

Protect Your Licence with an Expert Argument

Facing a mandatory driving ban or penalty points can have a profound impact on your life. A special reasons argument offers a vital opportunity to avoid this outcome, but it must be prepared and presented with the utmost skill and care.

Do not risk your driving licence by attempting this complex legal argument alone. Contact our expert motoring offence solicitors immediately for a confidential consultation and take the first critical step in building your case.

‍