Tax Evasion / Cheating the Public Revenue

An investigation by HMRC for tax evasion or the even more serious offence of Cheating the Public Revenue is a deeply worrying experience. These are not simple compliance issues; they are criminal allegations that you have acted dishonestly to avoid paying tax. HMRC has extensive powers to investigate, and a prosecution can lead to a substantial prison sentence, crippling financial penalties, and irreversible damage to your personal and professional reputation. Facing such an investigation requires immediate and highly specialised legal advice.

At Central Chambers Law, our senior legal consultants are experts in defending clients against the most serious tax fraud allegations. We possess an in-depth understanding of the complex legislation and the aggressive strategies employed by HMRC's specialist criminal investigators. Our function is to provide a formidable, strategic defence that protects your rights, challenges the evidence, and navigates you through this high-stakes process. We are specialists with the expertise required to manage these intricate cases effectively.

Understanding the Offences: Tax Evasion vs. Cheating the Public Revenue

While often used interchangeably, these are distinct legal concepts targeting dishonest tax conduct.

• Statutory Tax Evasion: This refers to a range of specific criminal offences under various statutes, such as the Taxes Management Act 1970. A common example is the fraudulent evasion of income tax, which involves knowingly being concerned in fraudulent activity with the intention of evading tax liabilities.
• Cheating the Public Revenue: This is an ancient and extremely serious common law offence. It is not defined in a statute but by centuries of case law. It covers any form of dishonest conduct intended to prejudice HMRC or deprive the Crown of money to which it is entitled. Because of its breadth and severity, it is often reserved for the most significant and complex tax fraud cases.

The Key Elements of the Offences

To secure a conviction, HMRC must prove a dishonest intent. An honest mistake or a genuine misunderstanding about complex tax rules is not a crime.

For a conviction of Cheating the Public Revenue, the prosecution must prove:

1. An Act or Omission: You took some action (e.g., submitting a false document) or failed to do something (e.g., failing to declare income).
2. Prejudice to the Revenue: The action or omission had the effect of potentially or actually depriving HMRC of tax revenue.
3. Dishonesty: Your conduct was dishonest by the standards of ordinary, decent people.

For statutory Tax Evasion, the elements are similar, requiring proof that you were knowingly concerned in fraudulent conduct with the specific intent to evade a tax liability.

How HMRC Investigates Tax Fraud

HMRC's criminal investigation units have vast powers to build a case against you. An investigation, often known as a Code of Practice 9 (COP9) investigation, is highly intrusive and can be lengthy.

Common investigative methods include:

• Dawn Raids: Unannounced searches of your home and business premises to seize documents, computers, and other evidence.
• Production Orders: Forcing banks, accountants, and other third parties to hand over all your financial information.
• Forensic Accounting: HMRC employs its own experts to analyse financial records, trace funds, and identify undeclared income or inflated expenses.
• Interviews Under Caution: You will be formally interviewed by investigators. What you say in this interview is critical and will be used as evidence.

HMRC's objective is to assemble a body of evidence to prove beyond a doubt that you acted deliberately and dishonestly.

Why Central Chambers Law Provides the Definitive Defence

Defending a serious tax fraud allegation is a specialist task. It requires a legal team with the expertise to challenge HMRC's evidence and navigate its unique procedures. A general criminal lawyer is unlikely to have the specific knowledge required.

Clients trust Central Chambers Law because we are experts in this precise area of law. Our reputation is founded on our ability to engage with HMRC's investigators and forensically dismantle their cases. Our strategic approach involves:

• Challenging Dishonest Intent: This is the absolute core of the defence. We build a powerful case to show that your actions were not dishonest. We highlight the complexities of tax law, genuine errors, or reliance on incorrect professional advice to demonstrate a lack of fraudulent intent.
• Expert Forensic Analysis: We do not accept HMRC's financial analysis at face value. We instruct our own leading forensic accountants to conduct a parallel review of the evidence, identify errors in HMRC's calculations, and provide an alternative, innocent interpretation of the financial data.
• Managing the HMRC Investigation: We take control of the process from day one. We will represent you in all dealings with HMRC, including attending interviews under caution, to ensure your rights are protected and you are not pressured into making damaging admissions.
• Negotiating with HMRC: We are skilled at negotiating with HMRC. Where appropriate, we can make persuasive arguments for the investigation to be handled as a civil matter rather than a criminal prosecution, potentially avoiding a criminal record.

Our focused expertise means we are perfectly positioned to provide the high-level, robust defence needed to protect your liberty and assets.

Consequences of a Conviction

The courts treat tax fraud with extreme seriousness, and prison sentences are common.

• Cheating the Public Revenue: The maximum sentence is life imprisonment and an unlimited fine, reflecting its status as one of the most serious fraud offences.
• Statutory Tax Evasion: The maximum sentence is typically 7 years' imprisonment and an unlimited fine.

In addition to any sentence, a conviction will result in confiscation proceedings under the Proceeds of Crime Act (POCA) to recover the evaded tax and seize assets deemed to be the proceeds of crime.

Protect Your Future with an Expert Defence

An HMRC criminal investigation is a direct and immediate threat to your liberty, your business, and your financial future. The decisions made at the start of the investigation can determine the final outcome.

Do not face HMRC alone. Contact our expert tax fraud solicitors immediately for a confidential consultation and take the first critical step in building your strategic defence.

‍